
The moment…
Anyone who has ever stood on a dancefloor at 3 a.m. knows that what happens there is more than just “listening to music”. The kick drum keeps rolling, the lights go down, the people around you stop being individuals and the crowd becomes one body. We can call it trance, flow, the moment... Ted Gioia would say it’s the oldest thing music can do – and that civilisation has spent the last few thousand years trying hard to tame it.
His book Music: A Subversive History is not another textbook stroll from Gregorian chant to the Beatles. It’s a four-thousand-year story about how great music has always come from the margins – and how those margins were always banned first.

A jazz pianist who went through McKinsey
Ted Gioia (born 1957) is an American jazz pianist and music historian. He studied at Stanford and Oxford, helped Stan Getz set up jazz studies at Stanford in the 1980s and worked as a consultant at McKinsey and BCG along the way. He has written twelve books, including The History of Jazz and Delta Blues. Today he’s best known for his newsletter The Honest Broker, where he regularly takes swings at the music industry, streaming platforms and algorithms. A little bonus fact: one of his compositions was used in the final season of Better Call Saul.
In the book, Gioia describes a cycle that repeats itself from prehistory to the present. New music is born among slaves, women, immigrants and in port cities where cultures mix. The establishment first condemns it, then appropriates it, polishes it and finally turns it into harmless elevator music. And the wheel turns again. According to Gioia, conventional music history is boring precisely because someone crossed out the sex, violence, magic and trance – everything music draws its power from.


Magic or mathematics?!
The book’s second axis is the battle between magic and mathematics. Pythagoras turned music into numbers and ratios, cutting it off from the body and from what it does to us. Ever since, Gioia argues, there’s been a tug of war between those who want to experience music and those who want to control it. If you’ve read our piece on Angine de Poitrine, you know this topic is close to our hearts.
The book’s real strength is its stories. The oldest known musical instrument may be a cave bear bone with holes in it, found in the Divje Babe cave in Slovenia and made by Neanderthals. Bach wasn’t just a pious organist: he got into a street fight with a knife and English Page 1 of 2 spent time in jail. In 1956 CBS censored Elvis’s hips, and fourteen years later Nixon was handing him a badge in the White House. And when N.W.A. released Straight Outta Compton, they got a threatening letter from the FBI. In 2017 the album was added to the Library of Congress’s National Recording Registry – and that letter now hangs in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame.
The new masters
The book’s final chapter is called Welcome, New Masters, and those masters are the streaming platforms. Under pressure from metrics, playlists and Auto-Tune, hits are drifting back to pure Pythagorean control: everything measurable, predictable and smooth. Exactly the elevator music Gioia warns about throughout the whole book.
The optimistic twist is that, according to Gioia, the moment music starts to feel perfectly managed is the moment the next explosion is just around the corner. Somewhere in a basement, someone is already using technology the wrong way. Rebirth against degeneration, as we’d say.
If you’ve ever wondered why rebellion turns into an advertising jingle so fast, this book gives you four thousand years of answers. Highly recommended.
